The Ultimate Guide to Bourbon Brands: Navigating the American Spirit

Walking into a liquor store to buy bourbon can be an overwhelming experience. Shelves are lined with hundreds of bottles, from iconic names you recognize to craft labels you’ve never seen before. With so many bourbon brands to choose from, where do you even begin?

Whether you’re a curious newcomer or a seasoned sipper looking to expand your horizons, this guide is your roadmap. We’ll break down the best bourbon brands across different categories—from the foundational classics to the allocated bottles worth hunting for. Let’s dive into the wonderful world of America’s native spirit.

The Foundation: Iconic Bourbon Brands You Should Know

These are the pillar bourbon brands that have stood the test of time. They are widely available, consistently excellent, and form the bedrock of any good bourbon collection.

• Buffalo Trace: Often called the “people’s champion,” Buffalo Trace is a perfectly balanced, high-value bourbon. It’s approachable for beginners yet complex enough for experts, making it a top-shelf staple (if you can find it!).

• Maker’s Mark: Instantly recognizable by its red wax-dipped bottle, Maker’s Mark is a flagship wheated bourbon. By using wheat instead of rye as its secondary grain, it achieves a softer, sweeter, and smoother profile, perfect for those who find rye spice too intense.

• Wild Turkey: Don’t let its rugged image fool you. Wild Turkey 101 is a bourbon icon for a reason. It’s bold, high-proof, and full of character, with robust notes of vanilla, oak, and spice. It’s a quintessential “no-frills” quality bourbon.

• Woodford Reserve: Known for its elegant packaging and sophisticated taste, Woodford Reserve is a masterclass in balance. Its flavor profile is rich with dried fruit, citrus, and a hint of chocolate, making it a favorite for both sipping and classic cocktails.

Leveling Up: Premium & Small Batch Bourbon Brands

Once you’ve explored the classics, it’s time to explore bourbon brands that offer more complexity, age, and unique flavor profiles.

• Four Roses: This distillery is renowned for its unique approach, using two different mash bills and five yeast strains to create ten distinct recipes. Their Four Roses Single Barrel is a standout, offering a beautifully floral and spicy sipping experience.

• Knob Creek: A heavyweight in the Jim Beam Small Batch Collection, Knob Creek is known for its full-bodied, nutty, and oaky character. Their 9-year age statement ensures a mature, robust flavor that stands up well in an Old Fashioned.

• 1792 Bourbon: Produced at the Barton 1792 Distillery, this brand includes favorites like 1792 Small Batch and 1792 Sweet Wheat. They are known for their rich, high-rye spice profile and excellent value.

• Old Forester: As the first bourbon sold exclusively in glass bottles, Old Forester is steeped in history. Their Whiskey Row Series, including the 1910 Old Fine Whisky and 1920 Prohibition Style, offers incredible depth and historical storytelling in a glass.

The Hunter’s Quarry: Highly Sought-After & Allocated Bourbon Brands

This category is for the enthusiasts. These bourbon brands are legendary for their quality and their frustrating scarcity. Finding one at retail price is a major win.

• Blanton’s: The original single barrel bourbon, famous for its distinctive bottle and horse-and-jockey stopper. Its smooth, caramel-forward profile and collectible nature have made it a global phenomenon.

• Weller: The most famous family of wheated bourbons, and a direct relative of Pappy Van Winkle. Expressions like Weller Antique 107 and Weller Full Proof are incredibly sought-after for their smooth, sweet, and complex character.

• EH Taylor: Part of Buffalo Trace’s acclaimed collection, these bourbons are bottled in bond, guaranteeing a certain age and proof. They are consistently award-winning and represent some of the best traditional bourbon made today.

• Michter’s: With a focus on quality over quantity, Michter’s produces exceptionally smooth and well-crafted whiskeys. Their US1 Small Batch Bourbon and US1 Sour Mash are benchmarks for premium, sip-worthy spirits.

Hidden Gems & Rising Star Bourbon Brands

Beyond the giants, a new generation of distilleries is making waves. Keep an eye on these bourbon brands.

• New Riff: Located just across the river from Cincinnati, New Riff has gained a cult following for its Bottled-in-Bond bourbon, which is non-chill filtered and full of bold, spicy flavor.

• Bardstown Bourbon Company: A modern disruptor, BBCo is known for its collaborative distilling and exceptional blending. Their Fusion Series and Discovery Series are critically acclaimed for their innovation and complexity.

• Angel’s Envy: This brand finishes its bourbon in port wine barrels, adding a unique layer of ripe fruit and dark sweetness. It’s a fantastic gateway bourbon for wine lovers.

How to Choose Your Next Bottle: A Simple Framework

Feeling paralyzed by choice? Ask yourself these questions:

1. What’s my budget? Great bourbon exists at every price point, from $25 to $250+.

2. Do I prefer sweet or spicy? If you like sweet, go for a wheated bourbon (Maker’s Mark, Weller). If you like spice, look for a high-rye recipe (Four Roses, Bulleit).

3. How will I drink it? For cocktails, a solid mid-shelf bottle like Old Forester 100 or Wild Turkey 101 is perfect. For sipping neat, consider a single barrel or small batch expression.

Conclusion: Your Bourbon Journey Awaits

The world of bourbon brands is deep and rewarding. There’s no single “best” bourbon—only the best bourbon for you. The true joy is in the exploration, one sip at a time. Start with the foundational brands, explore the premium offerings, and don’t be afraid to try something new from a craft distillery.

Your next favorite bottle is out there waiting.

What’s your all-time favorite bourbon brand? Did we miss a hidden gem that more people should know about? Share your recommendations and tasting notes in the comments below! Ready to learn more? Check out our beginner’s guide on how to taste bourbon like a pro.

---

FAQ Section

Q1: What is the difference between bourbon and whiskey?
A: All bourbon is whiskey, but not all whiskey is bourbon. By law, to be called bourbon, it must be made in the USA from a grain mash of at least 51% corn, aged in new, charred oak containers, and distilled to no more than 160 proof and entered into the barrel for aging at no more than 125 proof.

Q2: What does “wheated bourbon” mean?
A: It means the secondary grain in the mash bill (after the mandatory 51%+ corn) is wheat, instead of the more commonly used rye. This typically results in a softer, smoother, and sweeter flavor profile.

Q3: Why are some bourbon brands so hard to find?
A: High demand and limited supply. The bourbon boom has led to incredible popularity for top-tier brands, and because bourbon must be aged for years, distilleries can’t instantly increase production to meet demand. This creates allocation and scarcity.

Q4: What is a good bourbon for a beginner?
A: Start with something approachable and lower-proof like Buffalo Trace, Maker’s Mark, or Evan Williams Black Label. They are smooth, affordable, and excellent introductions to the core flavors of bourbon.

Q5: Does a higher price always mean better quality?
A: Not always. While many expensive, allocated bottles are fantastic, there are countless incredible bourbons available for $30-$50. Price is often influenced by age, scarcity, and packaging, not just taste.